Sepp Blatter payment to Michel Platini was a 'conflict of interest' - Scala
ZURICH -- Sepp Blatter's authorisation of a payment to fellow FIFA executive Michel Platini without a written contract was a "classic conflict of interest," FIFA's financial compliance head Domenico Scala told The Associated Press on Tuesday.
Audit and compliance committee chairman Scala said FIFA president Blatter could be culpable of "falsification" of accounts over the 2011 payment of 2 million Swiss francs (about $2 million) to Platini.
UEFA president Platini said the money was owed from his job as an adviser to Blatter between 1998 and 2002, but there was only a verbal agreement for the debt.
"Both parties, the president and Mr. Platini should have recused from their positions because both are members of the executive committee of FIFA and they both have a conflict of interest," Scala told the AP in the first public comments on the case by a FIFA insider other than Blatter and Platini.
"Mr. Platini has asked the president to pay him a prescribed amount, which he should not have asked, which is why it is a classic conflict of interest."
Both Blatter and Platini are serving 90-day provisional suspensions, while FIFA's ethics committee completes a full investigation into the actions of two of the most powerful officials in world sport.
THE BEST OF ESPN FC
- Bell: Liverpool fans make themselves heard
- Cox: Leicester improving | Why Poch should stay
- Okwonga: Man United's market | City's title hopes
- Laurens: PSG's pre-UCL issues | Hertha's curse
- Highlights (U.S. only): Stuttgart 1-3 BVB
- FC TV: Champions League W2W4 | LVG wrong
- News | Transfer | Toe Poke | Fantasy | FC TV | Podcast | MLS
The case could end Platini's hopes of succeeding Blatter as FIFA leader in an election set for February, although both men deny wrongdoing and are appealing against their suspensions.
Scala is also head of the ad-hoc election committee which rules on the eligibility of presidential candidates, but he has no say in the ethics case.
Blatter last week said he had a "gentleman's agreement" with Platini over the payment.
"If it is true what they are saying that they had an oral agreement at the time they made the written contract to defer the payment, that payment should have been recorded in the accounts in 2002 and subsequent years," Scala said. "It has not. If you approve as a member of a supervisory board financial accounts which you know that 2 million are not accrued you have possibly done a falsification of a document.
"It doesn't make a difference if you do that in a limited company or an association. The result and the consequences are the same."
Scala stressed that it is an issue if "two members of the executive committee have an agreement and no one knows about it.
"It is their obligation to disclose it to the executive committee that they have such an agreement."
Platini initially cited financial problems at FIFA as the reason that he was not paid the full salary he was owed by 2002.
But the former France captain then said in an interview with Le Monde published on Monday that Blatter suggested that FIFA's salary policy prevented him from having a contract that paid the Frenchman more than then secretary general Michel Zen-Ruffinen.
"I worked for several months without pay," Platini said. "After a while, I go see Blatter: 'You have a problem paying me?' He says: 'Yes, I can't pay you 1 million because of the wage structure. You must understand that the secretary general gets 300,000 Swiss francs. You can't get more than three times his salary. So we'll write you a contract for 300,000 Swiss francs and pay the rest later.' And that's what happened. Only later never arrived."
Platini said he invoiced FIFA for 2 million Swiss francs in 2011 because he mistakenly recalled that he had been paid 500,000 Swiss francs annually at the time, and not 300,000.
It was the Swiss attorney general who first disclosed details of the allegedly "disloyal payment" by Blatter after questioning him as a suspect following a surprise swoop on his office in Zurich last month.
Platini was the election front-runner until Sept. 25, when he was questioned by Swiss federal police as between a witness and an accused person.