Featured Matches
Previous
Atletico Madrid
Real Madrid
ESPNDeportes, ESPN3 8:30 PM GMT
Leg 2Aggregate: 1 - 1
Game Details
Bayern Munich
VfL Wolfsburg
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Evian Thonon Gaillard
Paris Saint-Germain
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
US Pescara
Chievo Verona
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Guimaraes
FC Penafiel
7:00 PM GMT
Game Details
FC Dallas
Real Salt Lake
1:00 AM GMT
Game Details
Morelia
U.A.N.L
ESPNDeportes 12:30 AM GMT
Game Details
Bayern Munich
VfL Wolfsburg
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Evian Thonon Gaillard
Paris Saint-Germain
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Aldershot Town
Forest Green Rovers
6:45 PM GMT
Game Details
Atletico Madrid
Real Madrid
ESPNDeportes, ESPN3 8:30 PM GMT
Leg 2Aggregate: 1 - 1
Game Details
US Pescara
Chievo Verona
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Heidenheimer SB
TSV 1860 Munich
4:30 PM GMT
Game Details
RB Leipzig
FC Erzgebirge Aue
4:30 PM GMT
Game Details
St Pauli
SV Sandhausen
4:30 PM GMT
Game Details
AC Ajaccio
Tours
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Angers
Chateauroux
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Arles
Sochaux
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
AS Nancy Lorraine
Nimes
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Clermont Foot
Ajaccio GFCO
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Créteil
Niort
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Orléans
Brest
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Troyes
Stade Laval
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Valenciennes
Le Havre AC
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
SC Heracles Almelo
Cambuur Leeuwarden
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Almere City
Jong FC Twente
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
FC Den Bosch
RKC Waalwijk
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
FC Emmen VV
Jong PSV
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Helmond Sport
FC Oss
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Jong Ajax
FC Volendam
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
MVV Maastricht
Sparta Rotterdam
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
NEC Nijmegen
Fortuna Sittard
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Roda JC Kerkrade
FC Eindhoven
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
SC Stormvogels Telstar
Achilles '29
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
VVV Venlo
De Graafschap
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Guimaraes
FC Penafiel
7:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Terek Grozny
FC Arsenal Tula
4:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Racing Genk
KAA Gent
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Mjallby
Helsingborg
5:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Sandnes Ulf
Viking FK
5:00 PM GMT
Game Details
FC Dallas
Real Salt Lake
1:00 AM GMT
Game Details
Morelia
U.A.N.L
ESPNDeportes 12:30 AM GMT
Game Details
Santos
Toluca
2:30 AM GMT
Game Details
Newi Cefn Druids
Aberystwyth
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Prestatyn Town
Connah's Quay
6:30 PM GMT
Game Details
T.N.S.
Bangor City
6:45 PM GMT
Game Details
Arsenal de Sarandí
Olimpo de Bahía Blanca
9:15 PM GMT
Game Details
Tigre
Racing Club
11:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Atlante
Coras Tepic
12:00 AM GMT
Game Details
Mineros de Zacatecas
Oaxaca
12:30 AM GMT
Game Details
Correcaminos
Dorados de Sinaloa
1:30 AM GMT
Game Details
América Mineiro
AA Ponte Preta
10:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Oeste
Boa MG
10:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Icasa
CR Vasco da Gama
12:50 AM GMT
Game Details
Santiago Wanderers
Audax Italiano
12:00 AM GMT
Game Details
Defensor Sporting
Rentistas
10:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Liga de Loja
Club Deportivo Cuenca
12:30 AM GMT
Game Details
Universidad De Costa Rica
Pumas Generalena
5:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Honduras Progreso
Platense
1:00 AM GMT
Game Details
Next

Summer transfers survey

Swansea Jul 20, 2014
Read
Mar 9, 2014

Laudrup vs. Monk - were Swans right to act?

It's been over a month since Swansea chairman Huw Jenkins sacked Michael Laudrup, and the fans are still arguing the toss. Although it's still very much early doors in Garry Monk's reign, I thought it might be interesting to compare the two managers' figures to see if, on paper at least, anything has really changed.

Since the Swans priority is avoiding relegation from the league, I'll only be looking at league games. Monk's figures are fairly straight forward, since he's only been in charge for four league matches. Laudrup was in charge long enough to allow for several interpretations of the data, and since many regard last season's Capital One Cup victory as a milestone in Laudrup's Swans career (put simply, the side were excellent before, terrible afterwards), I have also looked at Laudrup's figures before and after that victory.

The categories I'm concerned with in this article are goals scored, goals conceded, set piece goals scored, chances created, and points. I'll be looking at per-game averages for each of those categories. Firstly, let's look at Laudrup's stats:

"Laudrup's

The most significant numbers here are goals conceded and points. Overall, Laudrup's Swans never outscored their opponents. The swing between last season's 1.3 goals conceded per game and this season's 1.5 might seem minuscule, but it is significant, especially considering Laudrup's side were only scoring 1.2 goals per game. In other words, this season Laudrup's Swans had started to leak more goals than last term without scoring more to compensate. The figures are small, but over time, a side that is routinely outscored is not going to win many football matches.

Laudrup's points per game numbers tell a similar story. Last season's 1.2 is by no means amazing, but this season's 1 might actually be considered sack-worthy in itself. As Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski explain in their book Soccernomics, "the average club earns 1.3 points a match [...] a club sacks it's manager when it averages only 1 point a match". If we look at Laudrup's figures for the periods before and after the cup win, the picture becomes even clearer:

"Laudrup's

Laudrup's figures before that win were certainly superior. It was the only period in which his side outscored their opponents (1.4 to 1.3), whilst the team's points per game tally was 1.4, greater than the average posited by Kuper and Szymanski. The after figures only corroborate the story: outscored 1.1 to 1.5, with a miserable 0.9 points per game. That's relegation material. Now let's look at Monk:

"Monk's

There are two significant figures here: goals scored, and set piece goals scored. With two goals per game, Monk's Swans are scoring 0.6 more than Laudrup's best. Monk's Swans are also four times more likely to score from set-pieces. The two phenomena are related.

Laudrup's disregard for set pieces is backed up by his figures in this category. In his first season as Swans boss -- a successful season by any measure -- his side scored the fewest set-piece goals in the Premier League. The change under Monk's stewardship has been immediately obvious, not just on paper, but seen on the field.

The one extra chance Monk's Swans are creating per game is probably coming from set-pieces too, which has led to more goals, and more points (Monk's Swans are hitting the 1.3 average). Monk's defence is no better -- it's been as bad as it ever was under Laudrup -- but unlike Laudrup's Swans, Monk's have scored enough to offset that problem.

So was Jenkins right to sack Laudrup? Monk's early figures are an improvement, but as Kuper and Szymanski have it, "any statistician can predict what should happen after a low point: whether or not the club sacks its manager, or changes its brand of teacakes, its performance will probably regress to the mean. Simply put, from a very low point, you are always likely to improve. The club may have hit the low because of bad luck, or injuries, or a tough run of fixtures [...] whatever the reason for hitting a low, things will almost inevitably improve afterwards. The new manager rarely causes the pendulum to swing. He's just the beneficiary of the swing."

Although I mostly agree with Kuper and Szymanski, I would argue that in this instance, Monk's set-piece diligence is responsible for at least some of that swing. Greater set-piece focus has led to the other improvements (goals scored, points per game, chances created). Would it be fair to say that a little more concentration on set-pieces could have saved Laudrup? The numbers say yes.

Perhaps Laudrup got bored after hitting his peak early with that cup win. His side was never the same again. Laudrup brought more than tactics to Swansea. He brought players, prestige and connections which the Swans might find themselves missing come the summer. In terms of the product on the pitch, however -- and but for better set-pieces -- Jenkins was probably justified.