Featured Matches
Previous
Celtic
KR Reykjavik
6:45 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 0
Game Details
FC Levadia Tallinn
Sparta Prague
1
1
FT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 8
Game Details
Skenderbeu
BATE Borisov
6:00 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 0
Game Details
Debrecen
Cliftonville
6:30 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 0
Game Details
VMFD Zalgiris
Dinamo Zagreb
6:15 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 2
Game Details
Sutjeska
Sheriff Tiraspol
0
3
FT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 5
Game Details
F91 Dudelange
Ludogorets Razgrad
1
1
FT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 5
Game Details
FC Levadia Tallinn
Sparta Prague
1
1
FT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 8
Game Details
FK Qarabag
Valletta
4:30 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 0
Game Details
Maccabi Tel-Aviv
Santa Coloma
5:30 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 0
Game Details
T.N.S.
Slovan Bratislava
5:45 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 1
Game Details
HB Torshavn
Partizan Belgrade
6:00 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 3
Game Details
Skenderbeu
BATE Borisov
6:00 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 0
Game Details
VMFD Zalgiris
Dinamo Zagreb
6:15 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 2
Game Details
Debrecen
Cliftonville
6:30 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 0
Game Details
Celtic
KR Reykjavik
6:45 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 0
Game Details
Zeljeznicar Sarajevo
Metalurg
7:00 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 0 - 0
Game Details
Sarpsborg FK
Aalesund
3
0
LIVE 47'
Game Details
Nacional
Defensor Sporting
12:15 AM GMT
Leg 1
Game Details
Olimpo de Bahía Blanca
Atletico Rafaela
6:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Figueirense FC
Bragantino
10:30 PM GMT
Leg 2. Aggregate: 1 - 2
Game Details
Icasa
Portuguesa de Desportos
10:00 PM GMT
Game Details
Goianiense
Oeste
10:30 PM GMT
Game Details
Next

Marcotti: A tournament to remember

World Cup 7 days ago
Read

Marcotti: Deschamps manages expectations

France Jun 25, 2014
Read
 Posted by Gabriele Marcotti
Jun 15, 2014

The system works

Alexi Lalas and Ruud van Nistelrooy talk goal-line technology and what the Honduras victory means for France.

Last week, ahead of the start of the World Cup, officials from Goal Control, the company that supplies goal-line technology, and Johannes Holzmuller, head of FIFA's Quality Control programme, expressed their complete faith that the system would work.

"Yes, we can trust the system," Holzmuller said. "We can be 100 percent sure it works."

One hundred percent? Really?

Then again, to paraphrase Kid Rock: "It ain't bragging if you say it, then you back it up."

And on Sunday in Porto Alegre, when a shot by France's Karim Benzema caromed off the far post, back toward Noel Valladares and then off the Honduras goalkeeper's hand, well, Holzmuller's words were backed up.

Initial TV replays suggested the ball did not cross the line before Valladares' chucked it back out. Only referee Sandro Ricci knows whether he would have given the goal, but thanks to Goal Control, he didn't need to make that decision. The technology flashed "goal."

Valladares tries -- but fails -- to keep the ball from crossing the goal line.

TV viewers were less than convinced, but then pictures started appearing on social media -- still photos from better angles. And they left no doubt: the ball was across the line. The TV replays came from an angle that skewed the perspective.

Any way you slice it, the incident was a win for proponents of goal-line technology. Until now, it felt as if FIFA was shoving it down our throats, flashing Goal Control's verdicts even after shots that bulged the back of the net. But this was the perfect example. It was contentious, it was hard to call with the naked eye, and if anything, replay showed the opposite of what actually happened.

Goal Control works, thanks to the seven high-speed cameras arrayed around each goal that take no fewer than 500 pictures per second. According to Holzmuller, they cover the goalmouth entirely and can even take into account things such as the ball's spherical shape being deformed by a hard shot or clearance.

Is the system quite as foolproof as he suggests?

Probably not. You can imagine some kind of goalmouth scramble in which there are enough bodies in the way of the ball that cameras are obstructed and the photos don't show the ball, but rather players' body parts. However, Holzmuller insists that in their testing, even with three of the seven cameras obstructed, they still got reliable results.

- Horncastle: Three Things -- France vs. Honduras
- Laurens: Benzema finds his happy place

Opponents of goal-line technology use the "slippery slope" argument. They say it paves the way for instant replay, which they abhor, and cite slowed games and diminished referee authority. Well, that horse has now bolted.

Goal-line technology is here, and it has proven its worth. It doesn't mean instant replay necessarily has to follow. But it does show how, in certain circumstances, certain technologies -- when used the right way -- can make an important contribution. And that's already a blow to the luddites.

Sepp Blatter's passing reference to replays and challenges at the FIFA congress might have been nothing more than pandering or testing the waters. He knows full well that at the pace FIFA works, they need to first put it on the agenda, then convene a study group, then get it past the International Football Association Board, then test it, then have another study, then kick it back to IFAB. We'll be well into the next decade before anything happens, if it happens at all.

But the debate is open. And it won't go away.

Gabriele Marcotti

A London-based journalist and broadcaster who covers world soccer, he is the author of three books, the world soccer columnist for The Times of London and a correspondent for the Italian daily Corriere dello Sport. You can catch him on ESPN FC TV and read him here twice a week.

Comments

Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, photo & other personal information you make public on Facebook will appear with your comment, and may be used on ESPN's media platforms. Learn more.